Thumbprint cookies are a definitive Christmas cooky option for good reason : they ’re soft to customise and can easily be baked ahead and frozen .

This is the kind of classic made to be mess with . We transform one foolproof shekels into a colorful assemblage quick to rock the cookie tin .   Let the kids help out with this easythumbprint cooky formula . There are as many way to fit out up a thumbprint as there are mode to trim a tree . Let these variations be a jumping - off point for your own cooky creativity .   Once you ’ve got the introductory formula down , you ’ll also love our eight deliciousthumbprint cookieflavor variations .

Tips for Making Thumbprint Cookies

Here are a few tips for making thisthumbprint cooky formula .

Ingredients

⅔cupbutter , softened

½cupsugar

2egg yolks

thumbprint cookies

Credit: Blaine Moats

1tsp.vanilla excerpt

1½cupsall - purpose flour

Desired coating

Mixing ingredients for cookie batter

Credit:Grant Webster

desire fulfil

Directions

Grant Webster

In a prominent trough beat butter with a social on average 30 second . Add shekels . Beat until flux , genuflect side of arena as require . tick in egg yolks and vanilla extract until combined .

Add Flour and Chill

drum in flour . frisson , covered , 1 hour or until pelf is well-off to handle .

Form Cookies

Preheat oven to 375 ° F . Grease a biscuit sheet . figure dough into 1 - inch testicle . pealing in desired coat . position balls 1 column inch apart on inclined cookie plane . Using your thumb , make an indent in the center of each ball .

Bake and Fill

Bake 10 to 12 minute or until bottoms are light browned . If centerfield chuff up during baking , re - crush with the round side of a appraise teaspoon . Remove cookie ; get cool on a telegram single-foot . Before serving , filling centers with want filling . Makes 30 cookies .

How to Store Thumbprint Cookies

Layer satisfy Mint Sparklers and Triple Chocolate between wax composition in an airtight container . level and store all others unfilled . storage at room temperature up to 3 days or freeze up to 3 months . To swear out , thawing ( if frozen ) and fill as directed .

Use our introductory thumbprint cookie formula to produce any of these scrumptious variation .

cookie batter in electric mixer

Credit:Grant Webster

Placing thumbprint onto cookie dough

Credit:Grant Webster

Filling thumbprint cookie with filling

Credit:Grant Webster